Frame.io alternatives

In 2019, I took advantage of the "Starter Special" offer with frame.io: 1TB total space (250GB Live space + 750GB "Archival" space). We pay a low rate and get three users on that plan. We were told that as long as we continued to pay the monthly fee the plan would not change. Next week they're forcing us to version 4, and I cannot get them to give me a straight answer to the question: "Will we be paying the same rate, with three users, as we are now?"

Adobe technical support is the absolute worst. Almost as bad as Intuit - just copy/pasting boilerplate text from their website and not actually answering the question. So if they increase our monthly price by 8x, which is what I think will happen, we are leaving. Every time I ask them what I will be paying they paste in the pricing breakdown for the plan, even though I keep telling them the offer we signed up for was supposed to keep the price at that rate forever as long as we paid every month. Which we have. Frame.io isn't good enough to justify a price of $900/year.

All we do is upload files for client review, pretty basic. Files are typically in the ~10GB range, usually a ProRes LT or Proxy file at 720p, for color review and sometimes restoration review. We usually have 3-4 projects going at once, and 250GB has been tight at times, but sufficient. We need to have three people with upload access to the account. Everyone else is a "guest" user (client) doing approvals.

SAAS is such a scam.
 
watching this too.. much the same reason

current screeners are in the 100g range,
also use it to xfer Prores and DCP masters at around 500g
we use HD's for GAM's, DCDM's
have a 2Tb plan and sometimes add on a Tb or two for a few weeks

tried Sync for file xfers, veeeeerrrrryyyyyyyy slllllloooooooooooooooowwwwwwwww

BMD's cloud is a bit of a mystery, not much info about using it for cleint screeners / notes and it was such a trainwreck in the early days that i kinda wrote it off as a real deal, seems focused on shareing projects and LoFi media, something i'm not all that interested in

and yea, FrameIO support is not all that supportive
 
Quick update - I chatted for over an hour trying to get a straight answer to my question. Eventually I heard back from them with an assurance that our price will remain the same after the v4 update. I saved the chat log and screen shotted it for when I have to argue my case because the price went up. We shall see.

For transfers we've been very happy with Filemail. It's reasonably priced, so most of the time the $17/mo 1TB plan is enough. When we send client files we only allow them to stay up for a week so things don't get too backlogged. If we have a lot of work, it's easy enough to tack on an extra tb or two for a month, then bring it back down. Support has been responsive from them, and the transfer speeds are decent (we typically see about 400-450mbps on our 1gbps connection. That said, frame.io is consistently just under 1gbps for uploads so it is faster. But I can live with the filemail speeds we get.
 
For transfers we've been very happy with Filemail. It's reasonably priced, so most of the time the $17/mo 1TB plan is enough. When we send client files we only allow them to stay up for a week so things don't get too backlogged. If we have a lot of work, it's easy enough to tack on an extra tb or two for a month, then bring it back down. Support has been responsive from them, and the transfer speeds are decent (we typically see about 400-450mbps on our 1gbps connection. That said, frame.io is consistently just under 1gbps for uploads so it is faster. But I can live with the filemail speeds we get.

My problem with Filemail (which our biggest client uses) is that they heavily throttle upload speeds. We have 2GB fiber out here in the desert (2GB up and down), but I don't think we can even get even 100Mbps from Filemail. Frame.io is much faster, and Massive is faster still... but both are much more expensive than Filemail. My take is, "you get what you pay for." Filemail support was of little help except to promise there was a big internal server update coming in a few months and they felt their speed would probably double at that time, but couldn't give me a firm date.
 
My problem with Filemail (which our biggest client uses) is that they heavily throttle upload speeds. We have 2GB fiber out here in the desert (2GB up and down), but I don't think we can even get even 100Mbps from Filemail. Frame.io is much faster, and Massive is faster still... but both are much more expensive than Filemail. My take is, "you get what you pay for." Filemail support was of little help except to promise there was a big internal server update coming in a few months and they felt their speed would probably double at that time, but couldn't give me a firm date.
Something seems off there?
I use FileMail and I have 1g and get 300-500 Mbps 90% of the time.
 
My problem with Filemail (which our biggest client uses) is that they heavily throttle upload speeds. We have 2GB fiber out here in the desert (2GB up and down), but I don't think we can even get even 100Mbps from Filemail. Frame.io is much faster, and Massive is faster still... but both are much more expensive than Filemail. My take is, "you get what you pay for." Filemail support was of little help except to promise there was a big internal server update coming in a few months and they felt their speed would probably double at that time, but couldn't give me a firm date.
I can recommend trying Smash. We switched to it to have a teams-based WeTransfer alternative. It’s fast but I’d perhaps not say the best for transfer over 100 GB sadly. I easily saturate 1Gb up and down.
 
We've been using Klash for about 2-3 years and can warmly recommend it. I know the developers personally and they're super fast with implementation if we have any feedback , bug reports or feature requests. If you wanna know more I'm happy to put you in contact with the team!
 
We use Iconik.io. It is Bring-Your-Own-Storage friendly, so we naturally use Backblaze @ $6/TB/mo.

Iconik pricing is for your team, you must have 1 Power User (Admin) at ~$50/mo and then each regular user is ~$30/mo.

They have recently overhauled their client review experience and debuted a review app as well that is pretty nice. We like the very transparent al-a-carte approach so that we are never surprised with BS charges for "egress" or charging for clients that want to upload or comment on review links.

Over the pandemic, nearly all data transfer services realized that they were leaving money on the table by providing egress for free. I've seen the biggest changes in pricing structure around egress specifically, and I feel like many of these services are no longer providing storage in the way customers think. Example: You buy a 20tb Dropbox plan and then Dropbox limits how much you can upload per/day/week/etc. So you can never upload 20tb and download 20tb in one go. My stance is that it is misleading. Effectively what these companies have done is synonymous to Banks charging for a bank account and, separately, for access to your account. It is a double dip scheme, and is intentionally vague in the marketing of these products. </rant>
 
Another issue we had before we left Frame.io is that they charge for collaborators, EVEN when the collaborator has their own paid Frame.io account. It is another case of double dipping. If you pay for Frame.io and join another users project, that should be gratis. There is no defensible cost I can imagine for the double billing. Charging for collaborators is a grey area to me, but understandable. Not, however, if they are already a paying customer.
 
Another issue we had before we left Frame.io is that they charge for collaborators, EVEN when the collaborator has their own paid Frame.io account. It is another case of double dipping. If you pay for Frame.io and join another users project, that should be gratis. There is no defensible cost I can imagine for the double billing. Charging for collaborators is a grey area to me, but understandable. Not, however, if they are already a paying customer.
This makes my brain burn as well. Hate their policy here.
 
they charge for collaborators, EVEN when the collaborator has their own paid Frame.io account. It is another case of double dipping.

This is originally from the Dropbox playbook. One of the benefits of being a cloud provider is obscurity, i.e. what am I paying for and what are my collaborators paying for. Most users aren't aware of double-dipping, but it's a key part of the business model.

What's even worse is when you've been invited to collaborate with a shared folder (for instance editorial sharing cut and reference files with you as a colorist) and over time that folder grows to a point that bumps you over your account limit. You are then forced to upgrade to a larger account to keep collaborating over files you may not even need access to, like old cut or reference file versions that are important to the editor, but not to you as a colorist.
 
What's even worse is when you've been invited to collaborate with a shared folder (for instance editorial sharing cut and reference files with you as a colorist) and over time that folder grows to a point that bumps you over your account limit. You are then forced to upgrade to a larger account to keep collaborating over files you may not even need access to, for instance old cut or reference file versions that are important to the editor, but not to you as a colorist.

This 100%. We have been roped into very expensive plans for several different services under similar circumstances. Now days, client provides a portal or we provide one for upload/download/review. We wont sign up to any sort of 'collaboration' scenario unless they are comping the required accounts.
 
My problem with Filemail (which our biggest client uses) is that they heavily throttle upload speeds. We have 2GB fiber out here in the desert (2GB up and down), but I don't think we can even get even 100Mbps from Filemail.

This is not an issue we've seen, which would suggest it's not "throttling" (that implies intent), but some kind of network issue - probably one out of your control. We do see faster speeds with frame.io, yes. But we also don't upload 1TB at a time there, so I can't say for sure whether the faster speeds we see would be sustained. On our 1gpbs internet connection, filemail is reliably in the 400-500mbps range.
 
Back
Top